THE TUNA TRAP OF CARLOFORTE

HOME ALBUM FOTO CHI SONO RACCONTI FANTASTICI STORIE DI MARE MUSEO MARINARO CAMOGLI STORIE DI FARI LINKS

 

 

THE TUNA TRAP OF CARLOFORTE 

By Annamaria "Lilla" Mariotti  and John Mark Dean

P Isola di San Pietro, (Saint Peter’s Island), is also known as the Island of Carloforte from the name of its only town, as well as the Green island.  It was called the Island of the hawks by the Romans and is known as the island of the Queen’s Hawks, after the falcon named for Eleonora d'Arborea who ruled Sardinia in the XIV Century.   It is found at 39 degrees and 9 minutes North latitude and 8 degrees and 16 minutes East longitude, or more easily by looking on the map at the southwest corner of Sardinia.  It has an area of 52.000 hectares (128,492 acres) with 30 km (18 miles) of coastline.  There are about 7000 residents but with the arrival of tourists during the summer, the population on the island becomes at least 50.000.

 This is a small island and a magic world with an ancient story.  The first visitors to the island that confronted the native Sards, with a Palaeolithic history, were Phoenicians who established trading settlements on the shores.  Carthaginians, who coveted the copper and tin mineral resources of the southeast corner of the island, arrived in the 7th century BC.  In the 5th century BC, there was active trading by the Greeks from Syracuse, which is present day Sicily, who were followed by the Romans after their conquest of the Carthaginians in 147 BC. During all that time, no one conquered the native Sards in the interior of the island.  After the Moorish occupation of the Mediterranean in the 7th century AD, the island remained relatively obscure until it became a shuttlecock in the medieval era between the powerful families of Spain, the city states of Italy and the Vatican. 

 A dramatic change occurred when San Pietro was colonized in 1738 by a group of coral-fishers, who were natives of Pegli, near Genoa.  About 1500 AD they had been sent to the small island of Tabarka, off the coast of Tunisia, which at that time was claimed by the Lomellini Family of Liguria, to harvest the precious red gold from the deep sea.  Tabarka was a small rock and the community grew during the centuries until it was no longer possible for them to stay there.  There was no room and not enough food could be produced to support the population of the island.  In addition, they were living on a disputed border and at a continuous risk of raids by local pirates.  They finally succumbed to the pirates and became slaves of the Tunisian Bey, and their conditions worsened.  

 The King of Sardinia at that time was Carlo Emanuele III of Savoy, who was deeply concerned with the situation of these people.  He acted as go-between for negotiations for their release and, in the end, succeeded in freeing the Tabarkans.  He gave them the Island of Saint Peter (San Pietro), which at that time was uninhabited, to colonize and build a new free community.  In February 1738, 140 families from Tabarka landed on the island, and in only two years they built a town, with a stronghold, and fortified walls. They planted wheat and vegetables and immediately became fishermen.

 Even now, they practice agriculture and fishing and these activities give them a strength that keeps them together after 500 years and makes them a peculiar and unique people.      They transformed their ancient Ligurian based Genovese dialect into a local language called "tabarkino" which was spoken by everybody on the small isolated island, from children to older people, and they keep the language and other ancient traditions alive to this day.    

When I go to Carloforte I luxuriate on fine sand pocket beaches embedded in lava cliffs and swim in crystal clear waters under the glorious Mediterranean sun and azure sky.  But, in addition to the great physical pleasure of relaxing on the island and enjoying its excellent kitchen, I also had a project in mind that had captured my imagination. 

I wanted to know more about its famous fishery for the great bluefin tuna who are captured in a very unique fishing technique on the island.  The fishery uses a trap that is like a maze in the water.  To learn about the fishery, I first went to the factory where they process the fish.  It has been know for more than 2000 years that the tuna are readily fished here in large quantities.   But when I arrived with my camera, ready for an interview, a polite, but inflexible security guard would not let me in.   He said that the owner was inside and he didn't like curious people.   I was not discouraged by this and after a few pictures outside the factory; I went to seek information in another place.  

 I found a rich source in the small, beautiful museum that the local people have devoted to "their" tuna trap.  It not accurate to talk of the Carloforte Tuna fish Trap, but rather you must learn of the history of the Tuna Traps of Portopaglia, Portoscuso and Isola Piana.  In the local history these traps, which are close to one another and in the region called Sulcis, are in an interesting and complex way linked culturally.  

 Catching tuna fish with the nets has a long history in Sardinia.  It is said that the technology was introduced by the Phoenicians and the Arabs. However, there is no documentation to support such claims.  There is no doubt that fishing for tuna has existed in the Mediterranean since 8000 BC as bluefin vertebrae are found in ancient archaeological sites in Greece.  In the 5th century BC there was very active commerce throughout the Mediterranean and a major item of trade was a fish sauce called garum, made from tuna as well as traffic in tuna meat preserved with salt or under olive oil.  The Spanish had experience in their country with a large number of tonnara (traps) on their coast in the Atlantic Ocean and inside Gibraltar in the Mediterranean and were a major force in tuna fishing in the 14th -18th century.  

The nets of the trap or tonnara are placed along the northern coast of the island of San Pietro , in a well defined zone between the "Tacche Bianche" ("The White Rocks") and "La Punta delle Oche" ("The Geese Point").  The nets have been placed in this precise location for longer than anyone can remember and their location is shown on maps from the 17th century.  The trap consists of a series of six chambers or rooms with a total length of 500 meters parallel to the shore and another net leading from the trap and perpendicular to the coast, called the "pedale" or tail, is 1050 meters long.  

Nothing can be seen on the surface as everything is underwater, except the floats that support the nets.  They appear as orange, white and blue balloons barely disturbing the surface of the transparent and translucent blue sea. There is nothing to tell us that there are hundreds of bluefin that range in size from 30-300 kg placidly cruising in the trap, unaware of what lies before them. 

The bluefin tuna is a pelagic fish which ranges over virtually all Atlantic Ocean, from North and South America to Europe and Africa.  They live a very long time, estimates are they can be more than 50 years old, and can be more that 3 meters long and weigh as much as 1000 kg.  However, in recent years it is uncommon to see one over 500 kg.  The average fish caught in the traps is about 120 kg.  During April and May they migrate to the Mediterranean Sea through the Straits of Gibraltar to lay their eggs (to spawn) from the Balearic Islands in the western Mediterranean to the southern coast of Turkey in the east.  At one time, they spawned in the Black Sea.  Aristotle thought that the Black Sea was the most important site for the spawning of the bluefin, but no bluefin have come out of the Black Sea since 1985 because of pollution and overfishing.   

The bluefin swim close to the shore until they make contact with the pedale net (the tail).  The pedale net does not capture the fish but turns the tuna away from the shore to the sea, as they realize that they are more vulnerable in shallow water and they head for deeper water.   As they travel along the tail net, they encounter the trap.   Both the tail and the trap were originally made of coconut fiber mesh, but are now made of nylon.  The school of tuna then  enters  the first room of the tuna trap, the "camera di levante" ("east room")  and pass through the different "rooms" of the trap,  with its many doors, they move into the "camera grande" ("big room") and from there into another room the "bastardo"  and then into the "bordonaro", thence  into the "camera di ponente"  ("west room") and finally into the "camera della morte" ("death room") from which there is no escape. 

Some of the practices have changed but the fundamental elements of the mattanza are still followed.  The day of the "mattanza”, the fishermen will gather around the Rais, (the head fisherman) their hats off, and pray together.  At the end of the prayer the Rais, with a loud voice, would say "In nome de Diu, molla!"  ("In God's name, let go!").  This was the signal to open the doors of the net and let the bluefin pass into the death room.  The Rais would then give a second order: "Leva!" ("Rise"!).   At this order all the fishermen ("Tonnarotti") (the name given locally to these fishermen) with shouts, archaic songs, and enthusiastic salacious cries would lift the big net with the strength of their arms. The "Tonnarotti" who are on big boats called "vascelli” and directed by the Rais, start the "mattanza".  The final event in the capture of the tuna in the trap is the harvest, the "mattanza", a word of Spanish origin which means "to kill".  The mattanza takes place in the camera della morte; the room of death.  As the bottom of the net of the camera della morte lifts the tuna to the surface, the frantic fish beat the surface off the sea into white foam with the almost deafening sound of thrashing water made by rapidly vibrating fins and shaking tails.     

 The boats are put into a square, the net is raised and the tuna are permitted to swim to exhaustion.  When they are quiet, the fish are hooked one by one and pulled by several men on the rope to the edge of the boat and raised over the gunwale.  They are carefully handled to avoid bruising, a difficult thing to do with such a large fish, and placed in the bottom of the barge.  A few skilful tonnaroti make a clean well placed incision with a knife into an artery and the fish quickly and painlessly bleed to death.  When all the fish are harvested, they are washed, covered with ice and a shade and hauled to the pier.  The fish are removed individually from the barge, weighed and a buyer makes a decision on the quality of that fish,  Quality factors are the fat content of the muscle, color, muscle texture, size of the fish (it is not always the biggest fish that has the best market value),and the shape and overall condition. The best fish are bought for export to the Tsukiji auction in Tokyo, Japan and the remainder enter the local market.  The fish are then moved to a clean refrigerated room for cleaning and after cleaning they are placed in chill tanks to drop the muscle temperature.  Bluefin tuna have the ability to regulate their body temperature and keep their muscle mass significantly higher than the temperature of the water.  The next morning they are carefully packed in ice with insulating blankets around them in shipping containers and transported by truck to the Rome airport where they fly first class to Tokyo.    

All the three traps in the Sulcis area are very old.  Portopaglia received its charter from the King in 1420, Portoscuso in 1654 and Isola Piana in 1698.    Only one processing plant is still working today, that of Isola Piana or, is more accurate to say, the trap of Carloforte.   The Isola Piana Factory for the processing of tuna does not exist any more.  Several years ago, the factory buildings on the small island were transformed into an exclusive vacation village with shops, restaurants and resort apartments and cottages.  The processing of the fish captured in that ancient trap was moved to San Pietro to the old processing plant and cannery in an area called "La Punta" (The Edge).     

This old method of harvest can appear to be very cruel, but the fishermen are doing deeds that their ancestors did for centuries before them. They sing traditional songs, together with exhortation cries, because the tuna fishing means welfare for the whole community.   If the fishing is good, the winter will be good; there will be wood for the fire and fresh white bread to eat and a good glass of wine.   The fishing season is short, the nets are laid in May and fishing will last for about 45 days.  At the end of the season there is a lot of work for everybody.    The nets must be pulled from the sea and repaired for the next season.   Some of the fish to be salted or stored under oil for preservation and the ovaries of the female are processed to make the delicious "bottarga".   

All this used to keep the population at work for the rest of the year.  But this was the past, now things are quite different; the tuna are not fished as in the past.   "We have not had many fish this year", the fishermen say, "Tuna must have changed their course”.  The tuna trap of Porto Paglia fishes no longer.  The Isola Piana tonnara now catches more fish than the Portoscuso trap.  In the past it was the opposite.  During the period of the 1980s, the traps were taken from the water altogether and the canneries were closed.  The tonnaroti of Carloforte and Portoscuso did not fish for bluefin for about 10 years.  What occurred to account for these changes?  Has there been a change in the behaviour of the fish?  It is hard to think so when the records are clear that they had not altered their course in several thousand years.  The bluefin has not changed; it is us that have changed.  Industrial and coastal development has changed the waters of the Mediterranean dramatically in the last 100 years.  However, the most significant difference is that a particular style of fishing boats, called purse seiners, catches the juvenile bluefin tuna before they become old enough to spawn even one time.  The purse seines have sophisticated instruments and used airplanes and helicopters to find the schools of the baby fish, until their use was made illegal by the international management agency, the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT).  When they sight a school of tuna fishes, they lower their purse seine, a flying "death room”, and catch huge numbers of small juvenile tuna.  That is unlike the ancient traps, which capture only sexually mature adult fish and do not move with the school of tuna.  The purse seiner can pursue them day after day. 

I had my last meeting with the tuna trap of Carloforte in their Museum, which is in the oldest building of the town, and where there are examples of all the equipment used, with models and the old cans used in the tuna canning factory of Carloforte, when there was a cannery. I saw the terrible hooks that were used for the final "mattanza", the kind of ropes utilized to make the nets and the ancient machinery used to manufacture them.   In the middle of a room there is a model of the tuna trap including the nets, anchors, and floats.   Dedalo could not have built a better maze to catch the bluefin and make it possible for the men to catch them.  

The day of the "mattanza"  the fishermen used to gather around the Rais, their hats off, and pray all together and, at the end, the Rais, with loud voice, said "In nome de Diu, molla !"  ("In God's name, let go !").  This was the signal to open all the doors of the net and let the bluefin get into the death room and then a second order : "Leva !" ("Rise"!).   At this order all the fishermen ("Tonnarotti") unbridle themselves and in an exultation of shouts, arcaic songs, incitement cries they started to lift the big net with the strength of their arms untill, in a reboiling of sea-foam, fins and shaking tails ended the eternal challenge between the man and his prey.

 

   P

 

Back